Q: Can I use cake mix instead of brownie mix?

Yes, but the texture will be lighter and more crumbly. Brownie mix creates a fudgier topping and is less likely to dry out.

Q: Should I melt the butter or slice it for dump cake?

Both work, but they give different results. Sliced cold butter creates a crisp topping, while melted butter makes the cake softer and gooier. This recipe is best with sliced butter.

Q: Do I prepare the brownie mix before using it in this recipe?

No - you will use dry brownie mix (without the ingredients indicated on the box) in this recipe. The butter will work its magic while it's in the oven to create a fudgy, crisp topping for the cake.

Q: How do I know when chocolate cherry dump cake is done?

The top should look set and lightly crisp , with bubbling around the edges . The center should be soft but not powdery.

Q: Can I make a dump cake in a slow cooker?

Yes, but the topping won’t crisp. (See more about my Crock Pot dump cake method.) For a crispy texture, bake it in the oven.

Question 1

Why did my dump cake turn out dry?

Accepted Answer

Dry dump cake usually means the mix wasn’t fully covered in fat. Uneven butter coverage or using cake mix instead of brownie mix are common causes. Slicing cold butter evenly over the top helps prevent dry spots, and if needed, you can add a small piece of butter to any dry areas during baking.

Question 2

Can I use cake mix instead of brownie mix?

Accepted Answer

Yes, but the texture will be lighter and more crumbly. Brownie mix creates a fudgier topping and is less likely to dry out.

Question 3

Should I melt the butter or slice it for dump cake?

Accepted Answer

Both work, but they give different results. Sliced cold butter creates a crisp topping, while melted butter makes the cake softer and gooier. This recipe is best with sliced butter.

Question 4

Do I prepare the brownie mix before using it in this recipe?

Accepted Answer

No - you will use dry brownie mix (without the ingredients indicated on the box) in this recipe. The butter will work its magic while it's in the oven to create a fudgy, crisp topping for the cake.

Question 5

How do I know when chocolate cherry dump cake is done?

Accepted Answer

The top should look set and lightly crisp, with bubbling around the edges. The center should be soft but not powdery.

Question 6

Can I make a dump cake in a slow cooker?

Accepted Answer

Yes, but the topping won’t crisp. (See more about my Crock Pot dump cake method.) For a crispy texture, bake it in the oven.

Recipes Made in the Oven

featured at